| Product | Real Mushrooms, Lion's Mane, Organic Mushroom Extract Powder, 5.29 oz (150 g) | Gaia Herbs, Lion's Mane Mushroom, 120 Vegan Capsules | Nutri, Organic Lion's Mane, 120 Organic Capsules (633 mg per Capsule) | 21st Century, Lion's Mane, 2,100 mg, 60 Veg Capsules | NOW Foods, Lion's Mane, 500 mg, 60 Veg Capsules |
| Brand | Real Mushrooms | Gaia Herbs | Nutri | 21st Century | NOW Foods |
| Mushroom material | Organic mushroom fruiting body; no grain, starch or fillers | Organic Lion's Mane fruiting body extracts; no mycelium or growing medium | Organic Lion's Mane fruiting body | Lion's Mane fruiting body | Organic Lion's Mane fruiting body |
| Extract type | Mushroom extract; ratio and dual-extraction status not stated on the iHerb label | Fruiting-body extracts; 450 mg is labeled equivalent to 2.5 g dry mushrooms; dual extraction not stated | 10:1 extract; dual-extraction method not stated | 525 mg of 4:1 extract, equivalent to 2,100 mg dried mushroom; dual extraction not stated | Extract powder; ratio and dual-extraction status not stated |
| Labeled dose | 1,000 mg extract per 1 g serving | 450 mg extract per capsule | 1,900 mg extract per 3-capsule serving | 525 mg actual extract plus 10 mg BioPerine per capsule | 1,000 mg per 2-capsule serving |
| Beta-glucans | 300 mg beta-(1,3)(1,6)-glucans per serving | 83 mg per serving | Not quantified; label states 30% total polysaccharides | Not quantified; label only says naturally occurring polysaccharides | Not quantified |
| Organic certification | USDA Organic; certified organic by QAI | USDA Organic; certified organic by Oregon Tilth | USDA Organic; certified organic by CCOF | None stated | Certified organic by QAI |
| Testing and heavy metals | Brand reports third-party beta-glucan verification and testing for heavy metals, agricultural chemicals and microbes; no lot-specific COA is linked by iHerb | Gaia reports in-house ISO-certified ICP-MS testing for arsenic, mercury, cadmium and lead, plus lot traceability through Meet Your Herbs; not independent product certification | iHerb label says third-party lab tested and GMP certified; no product-specific heavy-metal results or COA are linked | Label says Guaranteed Quality Laboratory Tested; no recognized external certification, heavy-metal result or product-specific COA is linked | Packaged and quality tested in the USA with Intertek GMP facility certification; no public product-specific COA or heavy-metal result is linked |
| Other ingredients | None listed | Organic pullulan vegan capsule | Organic pullulan capsule and organic rice extract blend containing rice bran extract, rice hulls, gum arabic and sunflower oil | Cellulose, magnesium silicate, magnesium stearate and silicon dioxide | Vegetable-polysaccharide capsule and organic inulin powder |
| Active-value basis | $1.55 per gram of labeled beta-glucans | $6.19 per gram of labeled beta-glucans | $0.77 per gram of claimed total polysaccharides; beta-glucan cost cannot be calculated | $0.40 per gram of actual 4:1 extract; beta-glucan cost cannot be calculated | $0.53 per gram of extract; beta-glucan cost cannot be calculated |
| Price | $69.95 | — | — | $12.49 | $15.91 |